Vote No on Book Banners

September 17th, 2008 © by Susan Swartz

In the story about the national candidate who once tried to bully the town librarian, the details about censorship proved to be only partially true.

With the first mention of how the one-time mayor of Wasilla, Alaska tried to use her moose-bagging brawn to get some books banned, the internet immediately spat out a list of titles that were alleged to be on the mayor’s hit list.

For those already alarmed by this person’s politics, it was a tasty, outlandish list which included Harry Potter and Huckleberry Finn. But the doomed titles proved too bad to be true. There was no list. The story remains, however, that the mayor did indeed ask the city librarian if she would be all right with censoring library books. Seems that for some time a group of social conservatives in town had been pressing the library to remove books they considered immoral. Sometimes library books would be returned with pages defaced or ripped out.

The librarian said no way would she be all right with that. And a few months later the librarian got a letter from the mayor telling her she was fired. The mayor didn’t say it was because she’d been scarred by Judy Blume or Margaret Atwood, but because she doubted the librarian’s support, like she’d failed some type of loyalty test. Fortunately this sent enough shivers through the book-loving townspeople that they rallied behind the librarian and she kept her job.

A banned books list is a sure way to get many people inflamed. We don’t DO that in this country. Or at least we are surprised when we find out that some people actually try to do that. The idea of banning books is so un-American that every fall the American Library Association puts on Banned Books Week. This year, from Sept. 27 to Oct.4.

I always find the displays of books that someone once wanted to ban not only ludicrous but shocking. Imagine. “The Diary of Anne Frank” considered “a real downer”!! And Maya Angelou’s “I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings” challenged for encouraging premarital sex???

Don’t these people know about choice? As in, if you don’t like a book, choose not to read it.

In the story of the mayor versus the librarian it’s clear who turned out to be the hero. It’s also clear that the person who would want to maybe some day be leader of the free world doesn’t think a whole lot of free speech.

In Sonoma County we are rich in many things. Wine, olive oil, lavender, goat cheese, designer chickens and the like. Plus a healthy community of writers and thinkers of all persuasions. Every year for the past eight, there’s been a book festival in downtown Santa Rosa. The Sonoma County Book Festival is one of the few remaining book fairs around, the only one of a general nature in the San Francisco Bay Area. It happens this Saturday, a day long gathering in Courthouse Square, with author readings and panels on everything from memoir to mystery to the environment and football. I’ll be there, along with writers like Julia Whitty, Adair Lara, Noelle Oxenhandler and David Harris, at various venues, including, of course, the library.

Celebrating the art of writing and the joy of reading is a good way to counter the anti-intellectual fervor being stirred up in this election. Pick up a book, wave it high and say, “I vote for free expression.” It’s also a good opportunity to thank your librarian.

Listen to the Vote No on Book Banners Podcast at Another Voice on KRCB-FM

Tags: , , , ,

One Response to “Vote No on Book Banners”

  1. Tom J Mariani Says:

    Still laughing and seriously thinking about you presentation yesterday in Healdsburg. The subject of this blog is near and dear to my heart. The poem I had published in Santa Rosa JC’s “First Leaves 2002″ – - – “Lady at the Desk Wouldn’t Understand,” was not about books potentially banned, but the issues with the homeless using it for a drop-in shelter. I have revised it slightlu since then, and have written a few others about living on the street.

    Hope you have time in your busy schedule to make it back up to Healdsburg October 19th when I’ll get a chance to be the featured reader. I have a series of short stories, op-ed pieces, as well as poems. Gina was only four, sitting in the back seat in the middle of her two brothers, when our VW Bug dropped off the failing US 101 Tompkins Hill Overpass in front of College of the Redwoods November 8, 1980. Gaye wrote up my response to the “postponing” repair and redesign of the Doyle northbound approach to the Golden Gate Bridge. The PD also published an op-ed piece I wrote after the quake that damaged the Bay Bridge and collapsed the Embarcadero, “Bridge Failure No Surprise.” My longer poem “DETOUR” on my web site is about that early morning November 8, 1980 earthquake.

    Here’s a short one on being homeless: “5AM SHAVING and PAPER TOWEL BATHING at SAFEWAY”
    and why not
    It’s open 24 hours and always bright
    If you’re not in the shelter by 7 PM
    You’re locked out for the night

    I tried to get Dale to go with me to hear you. He had an appotment as a photographer. He, like you, is as busy in retirement as working full time.

Leave a Reply