Amour With Eyes Open
February 19th, 2013 © by Susan SwartzI was avoiding Amour, the movie. I’d seen enough previews to know the story line and it frightened me. For a while I was saying I’d sooner see a Die Hard movie than Amour. And I’d have to be dragged to one of those brutal movies. And then sit through most of it with my eyes closed and then rant about Hollywood glorifying violence.
But the story of an older couple with one in sad decline would require eyes open and there would be nothing to glorify except for the fantasy of living in a book-filled apartment in Paris.
I said, I’m not sure I’m ready to see this. My husband asked, why not? It’s about people getting old. We’re going to get old. The point is to get old, he said. I conceded.
My mother had Alzheimer’s. One of my best friends had dementia. I know those blank eyes. My sister and I vow to stash pills so we can end things before that happens to us. A friend said that when he starts to lose it his wife promises to push him off the ocean cliff. It’s a joke. Kind of.
My generation is famous for thinking we can age differently than our parents. We determinedly go to the gym, watch our salt intake, do crossword puzzles and take Spanish. We haven’t figured out a way not to die or not to get a terrible illness or be run over by a truck. But in general we think we’re maintaining better longer.
I’ve been writing about women and aging since I crossed into my 50s, nearly two decades ago. Back then the fear of aging for me and my contemporaries was not dying so much as being treated like an old person. The fear was of becoming irrelevant and discounted solely because of a birth date. And we’ve fought that well. Society likes old people so much they think we should keep working into our 70s.
But life’s realities have continued. My parents and my husband’s parents are gone. We’ve moved to the front of the line. “We are all becoming die-able,” I said after a funeral for a friend.
Right now I look at illness and infirmity in the way I approach life in earthquake country. Most days I don’t worry about the earth cracking open, but then there is a surprise jolt, a reminder that oh yes, that could happen here, too. To me, to us.
At the movie theater a woman in our row kept hissing to her companion, “This is so depressing.” Well of course, it was. It was unflinching. There was no sugar-coating. But it wasn’t unbearable.
And there it was, the final challenge, even for Baby Boomers.
We meet the couple, Anne and Georges, too late to know much about them. We know they were intellectuals, musicians and teachers and had a daughter and a swell apartment. We don’t know their politics. Or their friends. We don’t know how they met. Did they have regrets?
The 85-year-old actress Emmanuelle Riva, who plays Ann, said in an interview that doing the role exorcised her fear of death. I’m not sure the film did that for me. I know it did not exorcise my fear of losing control at life’s end. I’m still frightened of the prospect of my brain clicking off and losing my ability to be me.
But hurray for a movie that isn’t afraid to take a long, quiet, sometimes agonizing look at what we know will come to us all, in one form or another. And asks if we will manage it with grace and kindness.
My husband and I saw the movie on Valentine’s Day. We skipped dinner and ate popcorn and walking home, we stopped for ice cream. Two big scoops with hot fudge.
Tags: Alzheimer's, Amour, Baby Boomers, death, dementia, Emanuelle Riva, Juicy-Tomatoes, Paris, Susan_Swartz, Valentine's Day





February 21st, 2013 at 7:51 am
Hi Susan
I loved this…..very moving. I still feel a jolt when I have to pen in my age at 70 on a questionaire. To see old age at his finest, go see Quartet. I love British humor.
February 21st, 2013 at 8:41 am
“But life’s realities have continued. My parents and my husband’s parents are gone. We’ve moBved to the front of the line. “We are all becoming die-able,” I said after a funeral for a friend.”
Your quote rings so true. I haven’t seen the movie, but I will. When I see a frame of “Three Generations” and realize it’s not my grandmother as the oldest in that generation picture, it’s me, your “front of the line” comment hits home. I love Bob’s comment, “the point is to get old!”
February 21st, 2013 at 11:28 am
Thank you for writing this. I saw Amour with a friend about my age, and afterwards we sat in stunned silence. It’s beautifully done, an important film that needed to be made. And we need to see it.
As you say, we’re now the “die-able” generation, and it won’t do us any good to put our heads in the sand about how our lives might deteriorate. I hate writing that — I usually write upbeat books about senior sex! But this, too, is reality — better to learn about it and talk about it than deny or ignore it.
Thanks for opening the conversation, Susan.
February 21st, 2013 at 2:27 pm
I went alone ready to cry buckets. I did not. I left with dry eyes and a feeling that it ended as it should. Two lovers, old, worn out, ready to go and one in charge of saying when.
Thank you Susan for your comments.
February 23rd, 2013 at 3:31 pm
Hi,
Saw it and may go again. Loved the way music was used so sparingly (and an actual pianist played the part of the star pupil). The silence was profound and allowed such an intimacy. I realized this was the same Jean Paul T. of “A Man and a Woman” which I loved as a young woman in 1966. So seeing him old….was oddly consoling. I did not shed a tear, I was just rapt in appreciation, admiration, and recognition, having witnessed my parents. I supported everything Georges stood for.
February 23rd, 2013 at 3:41 pm
hi jane: and emmanuelle riva was in Hiroshima Mon Amour which I also loved and was maybe the first foreign film I ever saw.. Amour, an important film.. I’ll be cheering for it tomorrow night for an Oscar or two.