The Voiceless in Immigration Debate
December 15th, 2011 © by Susan Swartz 1 Comment »In the film Illegal Belgian police board a plane handcuffed to an undocumented immigrant they are escorting out of the country. The weeping woman cries out that she is being forced to leave her child and the other passengers immediately side with her. They berate the immigration officers who are ordered off the plane by the pilot with the woman. She gets beat up for her outburst and returned to a deportation center.
Stories of people struggling to make it in another country are a favorite plot line. Coincidentally it was in three of the last novels I read. The Northern African families in southern France in Bruno, Chief of Police. Polish war refugees in England in 22 Britannia Road. The young Irish woman in New York in the book Brooklyn.
Adjusting to a foreign land, learning the language and the culture, missing your homeland and feeling often unwelcome and suspect in the new country make good stories.
And we relate, since except for Native Americans, most of us wouldn’t be here had an ancestor not come first as an immigrant. Maybe in a proper legal manner, maybe not.
But then there are today’s undocumented immigrants. Lured here by the promise of work and a safer, better life for their family, like many of our own great-great-greats, they exist quietly, hoping to stay under society’s radar.
They are the voiceless ones in the middle of a loud, often angry debate over immigration. Republican campaigners argue over who would build the highest fence. Border vigilantes go on a hunt. The Supreme Court will get into it next year when it reviews a tough Arizona law targeting illegal immigrants. And the rest of us get all twisted up over what is the best way to deal with what we call “the immigration issue.”
Behind the issue are real people, of course, like Elida and Sam Mejia who escaped political violence in Guatemala in 1992 and came to California with their infant son Gilbert. They bought a home in Novato and had two daughters, Helen and Dulce. The father worked as a carpenter, the mother as a hotel housekeeper.
All was well until immigration officers, ostensibly looking for someone else, stormed the house and demanded their papers. And two years ago the family had to divide itself.
Their story is told in a short documentary, Sin Pais (Without Country) made by Theo Rigby and making the rounds of independent film festivals and social justice organizations. It will be broadcast nationally on PBS next summer.
I saw it at a Jewish synagogue in Santa Rosa where people don’t have to go back many generations to know about fleeing their homeland. College professor Madeleine Rose introduced the film and said that her father, a Holocaust survivor, came to this country from Luxembourg, also illegally. He knew, she said, that “a border can mean life or death.”
Elida and Sam Mejia were deported and forced to split up their children. They took their little girl, who’s an American citizen, with them back to Guatemala. The two teenagers, Helen, an American citizen, and Gilbert, who is undocumented, stayed in Marin County.
The parents and younger daughter are temporarily visiting California on a humanitarian parole and after the documentary joined the filmmaker on stage. Elida Mejia did most of the talking, at one point wiping her eyes and saying, “This is no life.”
The audience was crying too. Rigby, the young filmmaker, said he has found sympathetic audiences “even in places known for being immigrant unfriendly, such as Arizona or Texas.”
Immigration reform is not an easy issue but people like the Mejia family should not be demonized. They came here and got jobs, learned English, bought a house, paid taxes, educated their kids, bought refrigerators and cars. Give them the right papers and they’d be regular Americans.

del.icio.us this page




