Lilly and Sandra Speak Out, Make History
Thursday, March 8th, 2012 © by Susan SwartzLilly Ledbetter talks about the shame she felt when she realized after 19 years of working at Goodyear Tire and Rubber that all that time she was paid 15 to 40 percent less than her male coworkers doing the same job. She had worked hard, been promoted and received good performance reviews. But until an anonymous coworker tipped her, she didn’t know that despite her good work she was being ripped off by her employer.
When she sued for wage discrimination she won. But Goodyear appealed and sent the case to the Supreme Court which found in favor of the tire company because Ledbetter hadn’t filed her complaint in proper time. The rule was that she had to have filed within six months of getting the diminished paycheck.
It didn’t matter that she didn’t know, hadn’t asked or hadn’t even suspected she was being treated unfairly. That was part of the shame, I’m sure, that she’d been naively duped all along. Well behaved women seldom make history as the saying goes. Well behaved women rarely think to challenge or even suspect authority. They just assume they are being treated fairly.
The Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, passed by an unusually bi-partisan Congress and signed by President Obama when he first took office, expanded the time a worker can file a wage discrimination suit. Overruled were opponents who argued it would encourage lawsuits by workers who might delay filing claims in the hope of reaping bigger rewards.
Lilly Ledbetter never got the money she would have received had all things been equal. She was cheated out of a higher pension and a bigger Social Security check that should have been hers.
But the Alabama woman with the musical name, now age 73 and with a new book out called “Grace and Grit,” will be forever connected in women’s history with equal pay for equal work. And for speaking out.
Then comes Sandra Fluke. Who knows where the 30-year-old student will end up in history. She hasn’t even started her law career but she’s already making a mark.
Allow me to imagine how a Fluke entry in women’s history might be written some day.
In 2012 the United States found itself embroiled in a surprising and nasty furor over women and contraception, during a hysterical buildup to a presidential election. When it seemed that the rhetoric could become no more divisive and juvenile Sandra Fluke stood up to a radio giant of radical conservatism.
Accustomed to having his way with powerful men who quaked before him, the large loud voice of the ultra right attempted to smear Fluke’s reputation after the student told a Congressional committee why she believed her Catholic university should cover birth control in its student health plan. This set off the powerful puppeteer of far right politicos who slammed the young woman with vulgar epithets and even creepily called for a video of her sex life. He huffed and he puffed but Fluke did not flinch.
Outraged parents of daughters, including President Obama, rallied to her side. Activist women, already burning over a series of misogynist moves by the far right, went into full Facebook drive against Fluke’s attacker. Even normally silent leaders in his party dared to disavow him although its timid candidates did little more than tsk-tsk. Advertisers withdrew from his show and TV stations dropped his program.
While the name of her attacker has been largely forgotten, the name of Sandra Fluke stands for a period when women talked back to their bruisers and young women were roused from their long apolitical nap. And, in the process a nation climbed out of the mud, washed itself off and realized it is better than its blowhards. (That last blowhard part is a little fantasy of mine, but why not hope?)


